Spirituality

Spiritual But Not Religious? What’s Actually Being Rejected

4 min read By Anthony

old-and-new-wineskins

Jesus told a room full of people something simple about wine. New wine goes into new wineskins, he said. Pour it into old skins instead, and the skins burst; the wine spills; both are ruined (Matthew 9:17). It's a farming image, not a theological one. But it explains something happening right now among people who call themselves spiritual but not religious. Many of them haven't set the wine down. They've just stopped trusting the container. That distinction gets lost in most conversations about the phrase, which tend to treat it as a euphemism for quietly leaving faith behind. Up close, the actual pattern looks different, and it's worth understanding before writing anyone off as simply drifting away.

New Wine, Old Wineskins

The image works because it's mechanical, not moral. Old wineskins turn brittle with use. New wine keeps fermenting and expanding, and a rigid container can't stretch to match it. Pour it in anyway and both get ruined. Not because the wine was wrong. Because the container had already stopped being able to flex around anything alive.

That's a fair description of what a lot of religious institutions have become for a lot of people. Practices and structures once existed to foster a living connection to God. In plenty of places, those structures started mattering more than the connection itself. Renewal got treated as optional instead of constant, and the gap between the two grew until something finally broke. People notice the brittleness before they can name it properly. They just know something feels off, rehearsed, more concerned with appearances than with anything real underneath the surface.

Calling this a loss of faith misreads the situation. Nobody in the wineskin image blames the wine for bursting the container. The problem sits with a structure that stopped being able to hold what it was built to hold. That's a very different diagnosis than "these people don't believe anymore," and it changes how the whole conversation should go.

Spirituality Isn't the Opposite of Religion

Spirituality and religion get treated as competitors, but they were never meant to work that way. Think of spirituality as the pursuit of everything non-material that draws a person into a deeper experience of God, one that leaves them more able to love the people around them. Religion, at its best, functions as scaffolding for that pursuit. Practices and community exist to keep the connection alive. They were never supposed to replace it.

Somewhere along the way, plenty of institutions inverted that order. Belonging started to matter more than believing. Appearances started outweighing honesty. Jesus described something similar when he talked about dying to the self. He didn't mean erasing who a person actually is, but rather shedding the fear tactics, control mechanisms, and superiority complexes that grow up around genuine faith until they slowly choke it.

A person who walks away from a rigid structure while still reaching for God isn't contradicting themselves, whatever it might look like from the outside. They're doing exactly what the structure was supposed to help them do in the first place, just without the structure's help.

Why the Baggage Gets Rejected, Not the Faith

This shows up clearly in how younger people talk about their own spiritual lives. Many aren't rejecting Jesus at all. They're rejecting the institutional weight attached to his name — Sunday obligations, denominational labels, hypocrisy. Strip that weight away, and what's underneath often looks a lot more like genuine pursuit than genuine departure.

There's an old warning in scripture about a church that had "forgotten the love" it had at first (Revelation 2:4). It was busy, orthodox, and technically correct, but drained of the thing that had started it all in the first place. That description fits the current moment better than "declining religion" ever manages to. The love hasn't necessarily disappeared. It's often buried under decades of accumulated structure, and people are digging past the structure to find it again.

Practices Over Institutions

Once someone steps outside the old container, they still need somewhere to put the wine. That's usually where personal practice comes in. Prayer works as honest, ongoing conversation rather than performance. Scripture gets read slowly instead of skimmed for a Sunday takeaway. Quiet moments get carved out of an otherwise noisy week, on purpose, without waiting for a building to schedule them.

None of this requires a denomination or a membership card. It requires consistency, and a willingness to keep returning to a source of meaning that institutions can support but were never meant to replace. Whatever a person's church history looks like, the pursuit itself doesn't need permission to continue. It needs new skins, built to hold what's actually being poured now rather than whatever used to fit a generation ago.

Chapter eight walks through several spiritual practices in more depth, including a few not covered here.

Keep reading

Related Posts

Scroll to Top